The Law Offices of John J. Finckbeiner Jr.
Call Us for a Consultation

Do innocent people go to court and admit guilt?

High-profile cases often generate a lot of press when the evidence seems to suggest that a person is guilty and he or she fights against it, claiming to be innocent. However, what flies under the radar is that some legal professionals believe many people -- tens of thousands, according to one judge -- have admitted guilt when they were actually innocent.

The judge who made that claim said that part of the reason was that people would get nervous and take a plea bargain. For example, he said people may be looking at 30 years as a mandatory minimum sentence, if convicted. They would then be offered a deal that would only put them in jail for five years.

These people may believe that they had done nothing wrong, but they would still take the deal because they didn't want to risk losing the case and going to prison for 30 years. Obviously, this is just one example and every case is different.

The judge suggested getting judges involved in the plea bargain process. He said that would give them the power to look at the case and decide if the bargain made sense, to keep it from being offered and then taken in cases where the prosecution did not actually have much of a case.

This isn't to say plea bargains should never be used, as they can be a helpful tool for those facing criminal charges. However, this judge's opinion does show just how important it is for those who have been accused to know all of their legal rights and to understand how the process will play out.

Source: Huffington Post, "Tens Of Thousands Of Innocent People Have Pled Guilty, Judge Jed Rakoff Says," Simon McCormack, accessed April 20, 2017

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Free Initial Consultation

Call 504-662-1754 to contact either of our two convenient locations in New Orleans or Chalmette for quick, prompt and courteous legal services. Initial consultations are always free because we believe that everyone in Louisiana should have the opportunity to learn more about his or her rights. We are available Monday through Friday during regular business hours, and by appointment on weekends.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Review Us

Chalmette Office
Chalmette Office
2203 Pakenham Drive
Chalmette, LA 70043

Phone: 504-662-1754
Fax: 504-279-5375
Map & Directions

New Orleans Office
French Quarter Office
327 Exchange Place
New Orleans, LA 70130

Phone: 504-569-0277
Fax: 504-569-0278
Map & Directions